Learn about our history of service and dedication to our clients.
50
+
years in business
Our history and foundation.
JL Tillman Insurance Agency LLC was established in 1977 after our founder completed a General Business degree at Miami University in Oxford, Ohio, and gained initial experience with Aetna Life & Casualty. Over more than 50 years in business, our agency has maintained a steady focus on personal integrity and client-first service. We continue to support our policyholders by offering insurance solutions grounded in decades of industry familiarity.
Our approach as an independent agency.
As an independent insurance agency, JL Tillman Insurance Agency LLC is not bound to a single insurance carrier. We partner with established carriers including Liberty Mutual, Chubb, Progressive, GEICO, Foremost, and Farmers to compare policies effectively. This independence enables us to assist you in selecting suitable auto, home, life, employee benefits, and business coverage options aligned with your needs.
JL Tillman Insurance Agency LLC is located in Columbus, OH.
Our Mission
Our mission at JL Tillman Insurance Agency LLC, is to build enduring relationships with our clients by offering knowledgeable support, versatile carrier options, and straightforward coverage solutions.
Personalized Solutions
Get the power of choice with insurance that’s designed for your unique needs.
Knowledgeable Service
We’ll be there for you with reliable service and support to help you make informed decisions.
Trusted Relationships
You can rely on us to simplify the insurance process and advise you on your insurance.
Let’s Get Started
Request an Insurance Quote
"*" indicates required fields
Don’t like forms? Contact us at or email us.